Marston Hills: is it Hillcrest, and how do I know a home is really in it?
Marston Hills is a small pocket of Hillcrest, San Diego, generally south of Pennsylvania Avenue between Sixth Avenue and Park Boulevard, up against Balboa Park (Wikipedia). It is not a designated historic district yet, so a listing that says Marston Hills has to be checked. I'm Jared Harman, and I check before using the name.
Where is Marston Hills?
It is generally bounded by Sixth Avenue on the west, Pennsylvania Avenue on the north and Park Boulevard on the east, though some sources put the west edge at State Route 163 (Wikipedia). It is named for George Marston.
It's a tiny pocket of Hillcrest, quiet, and full of historic homes. Cypress Way is the street I'd point you to.
What is a Saturday like from a house on Cypress Way?
You're two blocks south of Robinson, which is a block south of University, so you're a three- or four-block walk from Trader Joe's, grocery stores, and a lot of coffee shops, like Lestat's. (Jared Harman's own read of the distances.)
Then there's the Pride Promenade on Normal Street. The plans include a restored 1940s trolley car turned into a concession stand, light poles with speakers and hooks for string lights, and a rainbow bike lane (Times of San Diego, July 2026).
When I spoke with the Hillcrest Business Association, they were aiming to make it a real gathering point, with coffee out of that trolley car, and I heard early 2027 for the opening. Reporting has the first park possibly open by the end of 2026, with the full project finishing in 2027 (KPBS; Times of San Diego).
What do old houses in Marston Hills hide that an inspection finds?
Foundation problems, or settling. A lot of these homes sit right on the canyon.
If you're buying one, put the foundation at the top of the inspection list. Here is what the big repairs on an old house look like, and what to know about buying a historic home.
Is Marston Hills a historic district?
Not officially, yet. It has been proposed as a recognized historic district (Wikipedia).
The city's 2016 Uptown Historic Preservation Element identified a Marston Hills potential historic district of 88 properties, but did not approve it (University Heights Historical Society).
A lot of homes get called Marston Hills anyway.
How do I know a listing is really in Marston Hills?
You verify it. If I were selling a house that is really in Marston Hills, I would back the claim with anything formal: county records, the city's historic records, and whether the property is on the potential district list.
I'd go the extra mile on it, because being in Marston Hills proper absolutely changes what people will pay. (Jared Harman's own read, not MLS data.)
Buying? Ask the listing agent how they know. If they can't show you, check it yourself, or ask me. You'll also see listings in Marston Hills where the agent never mentions it: what outside agents get wrong in Hillcrest.
What do homes cost in Marston Hills?
If walking to the restaurants and bars isn't your top priority and your budget is around $1.5 million to $2 million, I'd absolutely look here. (Jared Harman's own read, not MLS data.) Not many homes come up each year. In my experience it's a very low turnover pocket.
For context, the median detached house in the whole 92103 zip sold for $1,750,000 through October 2026, across 131 sales. Data: San Diego MLS via GSDAR, thru October 2026. That zip also covers the rest of Hillcrest, Bankers Hill and Mission Hills, so it is not a Marston Hills figure.
What does this mean if you are buying or selling in Marston Hills?
Selling? Tell me about your place and I will personally research what you would actually walk away with. That is a Net Number, back to you in 24 hours. Buying? Get First Look, my weekly list of hand-picked San Diego listings, because in a pocket this small, seeing it early matters.
Who is Jared Harman?
Jared Harman is a real estate agent and REALTOR® in San Diego, California, licensed under DRE 02193879 with MatchPoint at eXp Realty of California, Inc. He is based in North Park and works with buyers and sellers in Hillcrest, Marston Hills, Bankers Hill, Mission Hills and the surrounding central San Diego neighborhoods.
Jared Harman has 46 Google reviews, all five stars. He has sold $14M+ in real estate so far in 2026. His videos reach about 250,000 people in San Diego every month, which is where his listings get seen. He personally toured 800+ homes in 2025. In the last 12 months he negotiated about $990,000 in credits and price reductions for his clients.